The Obverse an original orange-Brown color showing considerable remaining planchet color around the edge.  The Reverse is a pleasing even chocolate Brown, typical of coins that spent many years in a Whitman-style holder.  I believe this may be a Repunched date, as the 4 definitely shows a "nub" sticking out at the bottom left serif - this can just be seen in my enlarged image (not great I know but the best I could come up with).  Similar to Snow-3, from the same Broken D hub and sharing a number of visible die lumps with that variety, however this is a different die.  A "no brainer" CAC coin - per their policy, this will automatically crossover to their own new Grading holder should you wish to re-submit the coin. 

PCGS 2118.63/36350582