Unquestionably original with moderate steel-gray color overall, some reddish-brown highlights on the higher points of relief.  I commonly associate this toning pattern with long slumber in a coin envelope or Whitman-style folder.  Fairly bold strike for the date, with a very sharp Obverse, the Reverse die showing a bit of stress lines.  Just a touch weak on the Bison's head otherwise better than most I see.  Unlike many of the date, including quite a number in certified holders, NO planchet flaws other problems of that sort.  No obvious marks other than the one on the Native's neck.  This has a shot at CAC based upon the originality and its "crusty" nature, although I would consider it a long shot based upon their persnickety nature (I have not tried it yet).   Please note that due to value this will require Registered Mail shipping, which is slower delivery time.

PCGS 3948.63/51855807